If I suffer… is God not good?
Exploring suffering, faith, and God's presence; sharing personal Christian struggles.

by | Oct 14, 2024

Available Now

🎙️ Brace yourselves for a thought-provoking and life-altering discussion on the “Thrive Podcast Network”: Episode 33 – “If I suffer… is God not good?” Join hosts Morgan May Treuil and Leslie Johnston as they fearlessly tackle the heavy question that haunts many believers: “Why does God allow suffering?” From Leslie’s raw and relatable battle with anxiety, which resonated with 80% of a student audience, to Morgan’s vulnerable reflections on her unhealed broken foot, this episode dives deep into personal suffering, the nature of God’s goodness, and the profound intimacy found in the midst of pain.

They explore everything from theological perspectives on divine sovereignty to practical wisdom on empathy and support during trials. If you’ve ever wrestled with life’s hardships or sought answers to your deepest questions about faith and suffering, this episode is a must-listen. Don’t miss out—this conversation promises to challenge your beliefs and offer comfort in your darkest moments.

If I Suffer… Is God Not Good?

Exploring the Role of Suffering in a Christian Life

As believers, we often find ourselves grappling with the age-old question: if suffering exists, is God still good? This profound query lies at the heart of our faith and challenges us to look deeper into the meaning of suffering and its place in our spiritual journey.

The Nature of Suffering and God’s Role

Suffering is an inevitable part of life. It touches everyone, regardless of their faith or morality. Yet, as Christians, we are often confronted with tough questions about why a good and loving God allows suffering. It’s important to understand that suffering is not caused by God. Instead, it is a consequence of the brokenness in our world—resulting from human choices, like the story of Adam and Eve, which introduced suffering into the human experience.

Spiritual Growth in the Face of Suffering

Deepening Your Faith

Suffering can be a catalyst for spiritual growth in Christianity. It compels us to lean on our faith, seeking solace and understanding in God’s presence. The Bible offers countless examples where suffering led to a deeper relationship with God. Consider the Apostle Paul, who despite his immense suffering, remained steadfast in his faith, teaching us that our struggles do not diminish our spiritual journey but rather enrich it.

Mental and Emotional Health Through Vulnerability

Faith and Mental Wellness

Discussing mental health, particularly within the Christian context, can be daunting. However, sharing personal struggles offers tremendous healing and connection. Leslie Johnston’s journey with anxiety and panic disorders illustrates how vulnerability can transform personal pain into collective support. By opening up about her struggles, Leslie found a purpose in her suffering, reinforcing the connection between faith and mental wellness. This shared vulnerability not only helps in Overcoming Depression with Faith but also enhances Emotional Well-Being for Believers.

God-Centered Relationships in Times of Trial

Building a Strong Marriage

Suffering also affects our relationships, particularly marriage. During difficult times, it’s vital to maintain God-Centered Relationships. Leaning on biblical marriage principles can fortify your relationship, grounding it in faith and mutual support. Morgan May Treuil’s insight into perseverance and commitment, inspired by advice from her father, underscores the importance of enduring hardships together, thereby Building a Strong Marriage.

Navigating Life’s Challenges with Faith

Biblical Solutions for Life’s Struggles

Suffering challenges our resilience and faith. In the face of adversity, turning to biblical solutions provides a pathway for Christian resilience. The analogy of running into the arms of a father during tough times illustrates how our relationship with God can offer solace and strength. As we navigate these challenges, knowing that Jesus shared in our sufferings gives us hope and assurance—His presence is a constant reminder that we are not alone, a cornerstone in Navigating Hard Times as a Christian.

Finding Purpose and Meaning in Suffering

Christian Discipleship and Faith Development

Christian discipleship teaches us that suffering can bear fruit, helping develop a deeper faith. Through personal anecdotes and spiritual reflections, understanding the role of suffering in Faith Development can be transformative. Morgan’s story about her unhealed foot reveals that despite unanswered prayers, the realization of God’s continual presence redefines our struggles. Such experiences encourage us to view suffering as a means of deepening faith and building a relationship with God. This aspect of discipleship challenges us to embrace our hardships as opportunities for spiritual refinement.

Practical Steps in Supporting Others Through Their Pain

Faith-Based Leadership and Compassion

When supporting others through their suffering, practicing compassionate and faith-based leadership is paramount. It’s crucial to be present, offering empathy without rushing the healing process. Drawing from the story of Moses, who was given time to grieve and rebuild, we can learn the importance of allowing oneself and others the space to process grief fully. This approach fosters a nurturing environment where healing can unfold naturally, embodying principles of Leading with Integrity and finding purpose in the act of support.

Conclusion: Embracing God’s Presence in Suffering

When faced with suffering, it’s natural to question and struggle. However, embracing the belief that God is with us in our pain provides comfort and strength. Suffering, though difficult and challenging, does not signify a lack of faith or divine abandonment. Instead, it offers a profound opportunity to deepen our faith, build resilience, and develop a more intimate relationship with God.

Understanding that suffering is a universal experience, we can find solidarity in our shared struggles. This shared human condition bonds us together and with God, proving that even in the midst of trials, we are never alone. As we navigate life’s challenges, may we always lean on our faith, support one another compassionately, and find solace in the unwavering presence of God’s love.


By focusing on these key themes and ideas, we not only explore the complex relationship between suffering and faith but also offer practical and encouraging insights that can help believers navigate their spiritual journeys with resilience and hope.

Related Episodes

Why being a girl is actually great for your job

🎙️ Wondering if you're navigating the professional world right? Don't miss "Am I Doing This Right?" EP34: Why being a girl is actually great for your job on the Thrive Podcast Network! This episode, hosted by Leslie Johnston and Morgan May Treuil, dives deep into the...

Here’s what he’s really thinking: Dating from a boy’s perspective

🎙️ Dive into the male mind with the Thrive Podcast Network’s latest episode: "Am I Doing This Right? EP32: Here’s what he’s really thinking: Dating from a boy’s perspective." Leslie and Morgan invite Jake Messner to break down what’s really going on in a guy's head...